The best Mac 'n' Cheese by whillsjournal on Eaten
Mac 'n' Cheese
7 reviews
AMAZING
1st BUFFALO CHICKEN MAC AND CHEESE
Out & Out, Cedarburg
Incredibly delectable mac and cheese, but a whole new level of flavor with the buffalo sauce merged right into the cheese sauce. Every single bite is so moist and cheesy and has the perfect amount of heat. This is perfection at its finest.
2nd THREE CHEESE CHICKEN MAC & CHEESE
Out & Out, Cedarburg
The blend of cheddar, provolone, and feta, alongside the tender bites of chicken and garlic breadcrumbs combines into a HEAVENLY macaroni and cheese. Absolutely amazing!! Speechless. Eat this. Please!!!
REALLY GOOD
3rd BUFFALO CHICKEN MAC AND CHEESE
Noodles and Company, Grafton
As long as you stir this up before eating, this is really good. It needs to be mixed thoroughly to blend its flavors together and evenly coat the pasta. The chicken is amazingly tender with a crunchy, spicy, and salty breading. The mac and cheese offers a nice cheese flavor with the spice for a surprising find from a chain restaurant.
PRETTY GOOD
4th MAC & CHEESE
Stack'd Burger Bar, Milwaukee
A side offering at a reasonable upcharge. Pasta was cooked perfectly, cheese flavor was good, but a bit gritty of a texture. Breadcrumbs were good though!
5th MACARONI AND CHEESE
Water Street Brewery, Grafton
A fairly creamy mac that lacked some salt until getting to the tiny bits of ham strewn about. Was a fine side, but not noteworthy.
JUST OK
6th MACARONI & CHEESE
Lakefront Brewery, Milwaukee
Sticky beer cheese is flavorful but a slightly off texture. Got cold pretty fast. Very average.
NOT FOR ME
7th PIZZA MAC
Out & Out, Cedarburg
I love this venue dearly, but this was an absolute whiff of a weekly special. The promise of mac blended with marinara, mozzarella, and pepperoni was sorely unmet. I’m not convinced there was any marinara in this, just a few small pieces of tomato. The mozzarella, if there, was unnoticable. The pepperoni was perhaps the biggest culprit, as it was a really greasy and off-tasting low-quality cut. The lingering aftertaste is even worse. This is fortunately not a permanent menu item, but I am still left with the aftertaste from this.