1st AMERICA’S TEST KITCHEN’S (ALMOST) FOOLPROOF NEW YORK CHEESECAKE
Soots Cook Nook, PrivateAlmost, because I came so close to pulling this off perfectly, only to stumble at the very end. It turns out that exposing a pale-topped cheesecake to 500°F of radiant heat for 4 minutes (the lower end of ATK’s recommended browning time) on the upper rack—which I mistakenly thought was the recommended upper-middle rack 😖—produces a very dark mahogany perimeter surrounding a small golden center.
Fortunately, I was able to salvage a few more presentable slices (this being one of them) from the lighter portions of the cake. Even more fortunately, the 4-minute blast of high heat proved to be only skin-deep. This seven-hour endeavor (not including chilling time) still yielded a smooth, creamy, pleasantly tangy cheesecake atop a toffee-flavored crust, thanks to a batch of leftover homemade Tate’s graham crackers.
All in all, a successful—and highly instructive—Cheesecake Day bake.