The best Cookies by sooty.m on Eaten
Cookies
93 reviews
2nd BUTTERMILK PANTRY’S HONG KONG STYLE EXTRA BUTTERY BUTTER COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Golden, buttery, fragrant, melt-in-your mouth noisettes of…hmm..BUTTERY GOLD? They’re not uniform (piping’s hard, y’all!), but each one is equally addictive. I had to make 2 extra batches to make up for the ones I could not resist popping into my mouth! Also my first time using more than 1 kind of butter (both canned but each from a different continent) in a recipe.
3rd BON APPÉTIT’S LEVAIN-STYLE CHOCOLATE CHUNKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
I may have died and gone to heaven with these glorious chunkies from Samantha Seneviratne & bon appétit. They are by far the best chocolate chip/chunk cookies I have ever had and what a great excuse to celebrate National Chocolate Day. 😋😋😋
4th BIGG & THICC WHITE CHOC MACADAMIA COOKIE
Banksia Bakehouse, The Rocks
BRIEF: “When it comes to cookies, there are few combinations as iconic as white chocolate and macadamia nuts. And now, you can enjoy this classic as a THICC Cookie! Packed with rich white chocolate and crunchy macadamias, making it the perfect treat for any time of the day.” SOOT’S TAKE: Freebie and also the best white choc mac cookie I have ever had.
REALLY GOOD
5th BREAD AHEAD’S ROSEMARY & LEMON SHORTBREAD
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Happy National Shortbread Day! Slaying it with Rosemary & Lemon Shortbread dinosaurs! The rosemary and lemon complement each other unbelievably well, even if the the herb isn’t all that visually prominent in the cookie, and even if each T-Rex looks like they’ve got a leg cast on and appears to be foaming from the mouth (with caster sugar). 🦖
6th BLACK & WHITE COOKIE
Russ & Daughters, New York
My first B&W cookie ever courtesy of @gooddayphoto (although it should really be Brown & White Cookie). It has a tender, cake-like consistency and I can taste almond which complements both the chocolate and vanilla icing. A most pleasant snack and surprise for how well it kept under its wax paper wrap.
7th JACQUES' FAMOUS CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
Jacques Torres Chocolate - Dumbo, New York
BRIEF: “Premium chocolate chunks that create layering from crispy to soft. There's more chocolate than dough.” SOOT’S TAKE: Solid CCC. Good chocolate : cookie dough ratio.
8th BEATRIX BAKES’ A SMOKY, SALTY CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Happy Chocolate Chip Cookie Day! This one and the rest of its peers aren’t as craggy as they look in the book, but by no means are they a cookie failure. Quite the opposite actually, and I’d like to think this cookie, with its far apart chocolate chip eyes is smiling at me bucktoothed, walnut warts and all. The smokiness comes from ground lapsang souchong.
9th FLOUR AND STONE’S SOLDIER’S POCKET-SIZED ANZAC BISCUITS
Soots Cook Nook, Private
If Anzac biscuits (back in the day) were as scrumptious as these, I hope they offered delectable relief to the austere existence of those who served and died.
10th BIGG & THICC CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
Banksia Bakehouse, The Rocks
BRIEF: “The OG, The Chief, The Prime, The Supreme Leader, The Samuel L Jackson of cookies. They don't call it the OG for nothing. This cookie is the original, the one that started it all. There are imitators out there, but there is only one Choc-Chip THICC Cookie. So next time you're in the mood for a delicious treat, make sure to reach for the OG. You won't be disappointed.” SOOT’S TAKE: Freebie levain-style cookie with a decent cookie dough : chocolate ratio. I prefer the ones I bake but that could be because I get to enjoy mine fresh out of the oven.
11th BUTTERMILK PANTRY’S MELTY NUTELLA TARTS
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Nutella rosettes atop buttery, hazelnutty, melt-in-your-mouth cookie bases to kick off the first day of Lunar New Year (LNY). They seem to have become a new staple in the LNY cookie repertoire in Singapore. Admittedly, piping is not one of my strong suits as it took several false starts: experimenting with 2 different brands of chocolate hazelnut spread, filling and emptying 3 disposable piping bags to finally arrive at these!
12th CHRISTINA TOSI’S CORNFLAKE CHOCOLATE CHIP MARSHMALLOW COOKIE
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Happy National Cookie Day! This cookie is a celebration unto itself! It’s got the crunch, the chew, the gooeyness, the salt, the sugar (rush!) and the buttery, caramel notes I so love in chocolate chip cookies. Pretty epic!
13th NISSIN CISCO COCONUT SABLE COOKIES - LEMONADE 日清シスコレモネードココナッツサブレ
DON DON DONKI JCube, Singapore
I love how incredibly crunchy these coconut-flecked cookies are. You can also taste the coconut and the lemonade without either overpowering the other. “A refreshing summer sable” is right! 👍
14th RASA MALAYSIA’S PEANUT COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
These are quite addictive for their incredible roasted peanut flavor and their crumbly, melt-in-your mouthfeels. I’ll take them over peanut butter cookies any day.
15th NUTELLA STUFFED COOKIE CUPS
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Molten Nutella oozing from brown butter muscovado cookie dough to go with coffee today is as decadent as it’ll get for today (and maybe the rest of the year).
16th AMERICA’S TEST KITCHEN’S MOLASSES SPICE LEMON SANDWICH COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Like colors on a color wheel, the lemony frosting complements yet offers a nice contrast in texture and flavor to the spiced cookies.
17th BOURBON ALFORT MINI CHOCOLATE WHOLE GRAIN BISCUITS アルフオートミニチョコレート全粒粉ビスケット
DON DON DONKI JCube, Singapore
These are so satisfying when those late afternoon hunger pangs hit you. Also, the first (and quite possibly the last) time I had these was sometime in mid 2016 on a flight.
18th HANDLE THE HEAT’S BROWNED BUTTER TOFFEE CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Been craving chocolate chip cookies (CCC) for too long and I’ll say the delayed gratification was worth it! The toffee chips and the salt really elevated this cookie on a day to celebrate CCC’s. #NationalChocolateChipCookieDay
20th PISTACHIO AND CHERRY AMARETTI
Dolcetti, Kilsyth
Pistachio and cherry amaretti cookie
21st BANANA EVERYTHING COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
While we’re still on the subject of muffin 🍌🍌🍌, these are also very good.
22nd TWIN DRAGON ALMOND COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
I don’t think I’ve actually had the ones by Main On Foods but Todd Wilbur’s attempt to replicate the original recipe (c. 1951) is impressive.
23rd THE WORLD’S BEST ANZAC BISCUITS
Soots Cook Nook, Private
According to the AWW anyway. I don’t know that they are since it’s my first time baking them and I don’t eat them very often. But I can attest to them being highly addictive and far superior to the few commercially produced ones I’ve had. They’re wonderfully caramel-ly and this is nicely complemented by the addition of nutty oats and coconut.
24th BAILEYS IRISH CREAM CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
A year ago, I baked Bailey’s Irish cream Cheesecake during a pretty shit week for humanity. A year later, here we are again, in a similar situation which many of us (if we are so fortunate) are trying to ameliorate with the healing power of baking. Again, can’t really go wrong with Baileys in a product we already love that is the chocolate chip cookie.
25th ALMOND SHORTBREAD COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Buttery and nutty in that special almondy way. 😋
26th NEEDLESS MARKUP $250 COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Milk chocolatey cookies chock full of oats, semi-sweet chocolate chips, pecans, walnuts, almonds. Made milk chocolatey by the addition of shaved Hershey bars. No idea where this urban legend recipe really came from since the story about a woman paying $250 for the recipe at Neiman Marcus was a hoax. Still, not a bad cookie to have warmed and with a glass of cold milk.
27th GINGERY BROWNIE CRINKLE COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
It’s a @nytcooking Christmas cookie day! I like em’ most when they’re fresh out of the oven and the chocolate chips are “still luxuriously liquidy.”
28th CHERRY CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Because I been getting hungry at night with no snacks to turn to other than water (or leftovers from lunch/dinner). It’s high time freezer cookie dough made a comeback in my life.
29th THE ULTIMATE BUTTER COOKIES (SOME SAY, IT TASTES LIKE JENNY BAKERY!)
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Buttery, melt-in-your mouth and just downright addictive! And no, they’re not mashed spuds. #onemore #inmymouth
30th THIN AND CRISPY CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Soots Cook Nook, Private
Happy National Chocolate Chip Day! These were a really quick and easy excuse to dispose of an open bag of chocolate chips. The pay off was a batch of caramelized butterscotch-y cookies with thin, crispy rims and chewy centers. Took under 20 minutes!